WE NEED A NEW PARTY TO SPEARHEAD NO ANTISEMITISM (PALESTINIANISM) IN ISRAEL

 

As Caroline Glick and Martin Sherman among many others are saying the whole of the Operation in Gaza has been a defeat for Israel. Israel and the IDF did not settle the issue of Hamas rockets and tunnels.

 

War is not casual. There is always a decisión. More than that targets always have to be set. The main problem in this case is that war was not declared and no targets were set.

 

Netanyahu and his group who control the Media and the State in Israel must not be allowed to ever spin it in any way that suggests a victory.

 

If no war was declared with clear aims that is a problem. If no targets were clearly set another big problem

 

War was NOT declared. Targets changed as things developed.

 

I am proposing that this looseness of language, action, aims, targets, is a result of how Israel is actually governed.

 

WAR RUN BY ONE MAN AND ONE OTHER

The war was run by two people, Netanyahu and Ya’alon (Defense Minister Moshe Ya’alon)

 

The war, not called a war I repeat, was not run by a cabinet with the cabinet delegating. There was no delegation. Netanyahu decided.

 

It was also run by the Army Generals, that is the leadership of the IDF, in which Israeli Intelligence was involved too. But not by Cabinet.

 

A leader Danny Dayon was expelled from the Cabinet by Netanyahu because he did not toe THIS line, which is a line of ruling through a non cabinet cabal.

 

This is how no decisión was made to go to war and no targets were set, which resulted in something not war but “operation” (Operation Protective Edge), and not targets of war but tactics which were changing.

 

All of that has resulted in a failure. Every Israeli today knows that the rockets are not destroyed and the tunnels were not destroyed (Debka reports that only tunnels within a few miles of the border were hit by the IDF. Were they all hit? No! And that leaves the whole network in this strip which lead into these tunnels. The whole strip sits now on these deadly tunnels. And the same thing with the rockets, the majority still in existence in Gaza.

 

Politicaly too the war is lost totally. The Obama and Netanyahu line is to bring Abbas forward. But Caroline Glick shows that this is a récipe for disaster and for the introduction of rockets, powerful with guidance, into those tunnels

 

Lost too because Hizbullah and Iran are drawn in by Obama to this solution. That means defeat in spades for Netanyahu and his “Operation”

 

The question is how to form a clear point of opposition to Netanyahu?

 

4international has noted what a great job Martin Sherman has done in his last article in which he records in historical detail (Ben Gurion, Begin, Sharon) how Israeli héroes sell out at critical moments.

 

TURN OF BIBI TO BETRAY…BIG TIME

Now it is the turn of Netanyahu to betray. Netanyahu too is a favoured son of Israel, the brother of the Entebbe Raid hero, absolutely part of Jewish folklore. Caroline Glick has noted in great detail the ACTUAL (historical detail is her strong point) role of Abbas and how Obama, Kerry and maybe Netanyahu are pushing this person to the Forefront. Note as the UN was the front for Hamas in Gaza, as Caroline points out very clearly and above all comprehensively, detail very impressive, that now it will be Abbas, UN as front for Hamas.

 

http://carolineglick.com/obamas-new-plan-for-hamas/

 

There are many who are voicing the above feelings of dissidence with the ruling elite in Israel from the side of patriotism. (Note the use of left and right as commonly used in Israeli politics is not allowed on this site. These terms are meaningless in the broad world) (Martin Sherman I request you to be careful in using these terms…I have strong backing in this from Francisco Gil White, Jared Israel and Richard Landes)

 

But meanwhile back to this war situation and how practically to proceed.

 

I feel that complex issues can always be reduced down to simple things. In the case of Lenin it was BREAD the people were starving, PEACE the horrific world war 1, LAND many centuries of peasant oppression. (I know this example best so I use it and I think it should be used…this is not pushing “communism” even though I do that as well, and proudly so)

 

I see so many plans and schemes pushed forward by Jews. I know why. They are all trying to do their best and are so fearful of the future given their past.

 

But I try to reduce it to a simple concept. How about “Root out Antisemitism … out of the land of Israel”. Rephrase but keep the meaning.

 

To my studied political position as an irishman I hold that to throw a single Stone against a Jew in Israel (or anywhere on earth) IS ANTISEMITISM IN THE EXTREME.

 

So go figure! What does that mean in practice? it means it is ALL antisemitism in action today!

 

We can ask what does patriotism or authentic nationalism mean in Israel. It can have a religious aspect but still must be practical to survive … after all all human life is practical.

 

The whole of the campaign by Netanyahu in this Gaza Operation was an exercise in how to provide your Antisemite Enemies with all the ammunition they need to stir up vile Antisemitism in the world.

 

The biggest lesson is that the world is going to accuse Israel of being Nazi etc. anyway, whether they send warnings before destroying every empty house, whether they abort missions or not. So why do it?

 

The biggest lesson is that last paragraph above. Study any war, anywhere in the history of warfare and you will find that you attack the enemy with force and without warning. Also you do it decisively, brutally because war is brutal, and over as short a time period as possible. In other words you seek always to pulverise the enemy.

 

Those are the rules of warfare. But that is not adequate for this Jewish cabal who leads Israel since 1948. They want to have special rules for the Jews at war where the Jews are to be seen by the world as super humanitarians.

 

Why not just go to war TO WIN, end the war with victory in as short a period as possible TO WIN AND SAVE LIFE, having achieved victory and pulverized the enemy then be merciful if mercy is possible.

 

The very first consideration for a new leadership, as opposed to what has been in Israel since 48, is to face this consideration at the staart of this war.

 

Hamas control Gaza and the UN in Gaza is an arm of Hamas.

 

ANOTHER CONSIDERATION A NEW LEADERSHIP MIGHT WRITE ON THE BLACKBOARD AT PLANNING STAGE:

 

Evidence from Mohammed el Dura/France2 and from Qana (EU Referendum Reports) that the enemy have a vast Pallywood industry in operation.

 

We knew totally that the enemy control all aspects of the international media in Gaza, something which happened also totally in Yugoslavia against Milosevic and the Serbs.

 

So why did the Netanyahu group therefore do it like that, giving every opportunity and all of the time in the world for the enemy to promote their Pallywood productions and the international media to set up their extensive and long running campaigns of vilification of Israel AND OF JEWS?

 

I return again to these two great assets for Israel:

 

Caroline Glick has showed in the latest article in great detail how Fatah also is an arm of Hamas. This has great importance for the tactics now to be used.

 

Martin Sherman in his latest article showed how every Israeli leader since 1948, especially those with a bit of a name for bravery like Sharon and Begin, that they were a disaster in leadership

 

I cannot say that a Trotskyist Party can come forward this week or even next month and it pains me to say that. Trotskyisn was wiped out in 1940 by Stalin and by Hitler and by all capitalist governments. Roosevelt promoted Stalinism.

 

Nevertheless there must be a next practical step by patriots (Note again I shun the use of “Right” here a term that is lethally self-limiting for a great cause)

 

There must now be a new organised NEW party created on a platform opposed to a SECOND Palestine Arab state in Israel. Netanyahu has of course placed himself outside of this. Such a party is in opposition to Netanyahu. But note at times in unity and in defence of too.

 

Martin Sherman and Caroline Glick plus many others must continue their activity, telling Jews and the world the truth, but they must do it as part of an organised party which is in opposition to the present ruling group.

 

Of course such a party must defend Netanyahu and others who are actually our enemies if they come under attack from the Antisemites, but that is a necessary defence against the enemy, especially necessary to enable the discussion to proceed.

 

This defence of our political opponents becomes ever more necessary in a period like today when there is a Muslim Brotherhood man in charge of America with all the power that Obama brings to his mission to promote the Muslim Brotherhood. I return to this theme of how to defend Netanyahu at times agains the enemy precisely because of Obamam who is a Muslim hater of Jews

 

Now Obama clearly sees the need and the opportunity to rescue Hamas by promoting Abbas and Fatah.

 

El Sisi like Mubarak remains an Antisemitic Arab. The situation not to go along with Obama support for Abbas becomes ever more critical.

 

Israel does not need grand plans and it simply needs to find a way through a party to express its needs at each point

 

IMMEDIATE AND UNPOSTPONABLE STEPS

The very first step is to explain to the Israeli people that the Operation in Gaza did not and was never meant to defeat Hamas.

 

Moreover explain that Abbas is actually worse than Hamas. They are all part of the same Antisemitic scheme in the world against Jews and Israel.

 

That is the single most important issue to be fought out and clarified in front of every single Israeli today, and that includes those Arabs in Israel who love Israel.

 

It is a political and a practical task and not a religious one that has to be carried out. In this case freedom of religion means putting an end to Antisemitism in Israel. Start there at least!

 

 

 

ISRAEL IS NOT EXHAUSTED AS THE BBC CLAIMED THIS MORNING

THE SAME TASKS STILL EXIST! ISRAEL MUST TAKE OVER GAZA AND SMASH HAMAS! THERE IS NO OTHER WAY!

91% of Israeli Jews support the ongoing ‘Operation Protective Edge” and 85% would only support a cease-fire agreement if Israel eliminated every Hamas rocket and destroyed the full network of terror tunnels  used by Hamas to attack Israeli civilians, Arutz Sheva reports.

 

Top Pentagon intelligence official believes that the destruction of Hamas would only lead to something more dangerous taking its place – like ISIS.

 

The decision that was facing the Israeli leadership of the war was exactly that. Should Israel go on and break up the Hamas organization and take control of the Gaza? Or should Israel seek a deal with Hamas?

 

It is very, very unfortunate indeed that Israel in the first 3 days of the war did not take over the Gaza. This would have repeated the time honoured methods of warfare as practiced in Ireland by the Irish King Brian Boru against the Danes which is to take the ground that the enemy sits on and hold on to that ground

 

As stated above it is clear that 91 of the Israelis would have supported Netanyahu if he had done that.

 

I am absolutely certain that the great majority of the American people would have supported Israel smashing up Hamas in Gaza.

 

So why on earth did Netanyahu not do that in the first 3 days of the war?

 

This is the crisis of leadership in Israeli politics. 4international disagrees with Martin Sherman on this. It is not enough to ask the Israeli leaders to do it. It is necessary to get rid of Netanyahu and to replace him with leaders who will do this.

 

That is the next step. It was always and will remain the next step.

 

ISRAEL MUST NOT BECOME BEGGARS. ISRAEL MUST TAKE CONTROL OF GAZA AND SMASH HAMAS.

 

 

US called for “immediate ceasefire without preconditions”. Israeli leaders agreed and now appear to be begging

 

“immediate ceasefire without preconditions” that was the call that was made by Obama, Kerry, the British and the French and almost all others

 

But that is the wrong policy to have when you are dealing with terrorists.

 

Was that the call that was made on the British against the IRA? Was that the call that was made on the Spanish against ETA?

 

NO IT WAS NOT! There was no such call made on the British and the French and they both used the most inhuman methods against those terrorists.

 

The British and the Americans went to WORLD war against Hitler. They went to war and the result was 60 millions of deaths, but there was no similar call made for immediate ceasefire.

 

Yet Israel is facing the worst Fascists on the planet, Hamas and the similar PA of Abbas are similar to ISIL. Abbas is in agreement with these Hamas Fascists.

 

So there has been a double standard applied to Israel because Israel is made up of Jews and Israel is the Jewish Homeland.

 

There is another link between Hamas, Fatah and the Nazis of Hitler. That is Antisemitism or Jew Hatred.

 

The answer: 4international is in agreement with those like the Martin Sherman Facebook Page, and with the member of Knesset Moshe Feiglin, on a programme which calls for Israel to take control of the situation by breaking up these Antisemites, starting first of all with Hamas in the Gaza.

 

We also think that Israel should make close alliance with all of those like the Kurds who are in deadly conflict with ISIL, and should make an alliance with Russia and the Crimea as well as the southern Russian Ukraine who are facing the Fascists in Northern Ukraine directed by Washington

 

The Hamas is not a “Palestinian Militant Group” as they were called on the BBC news bulletin this morning. That is misleading. They are Arab Fascists. Arab Fascists filled with Jew Hatred. The BBC cannot get it right because the BBC is also filled with Jew Hatred.

 

NEEDED A NEW BEGINNING FOR ISRAEL AND MARTIN SHERMAN DOES NOT PROVIDE IT

Leon Trotsky with Diego Rivero in the 30s

 

Martin Sherman makes vital points such as

 

“As a result, the political “Right” has found itself unable to respond effectively to the pointed and pertinent question from “left-wing” adversaries: “So what’s your alternative?” With no comprehensive countervailing paradigmatic position to promote or defend, the “Right” found itself gradually forced to give way under the weight of this onerous question, and to adopt increasing portions of the failed formula it had rejected.”

http://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Columnists/Into-the-Fray-The-rout-of-the-Right-354837

 

The defence of Israel as the Jewish Homeland is also the war internationally against Islam, and it must also be the war against political elites in the world in general, especially a necessary war against the Vatican (bit not against the Christian or Catholic people who themselves are being betrayed by the Churches and the Vatican in their own struggle against Islam)

 

As if all that were not hard enough remember also that we live in a period of deepening crisis in the international capitalist system where the drive in the world is towards class dictatorship, morphing into Fascist states. The latter raises the issue, as it has always historically done, of growing Antisemitism. This Antisemitism has something new, a coalition of US Presidents, of anti-Marxist Fascistsm of Islam and all against Jews and Israel.

 

Sherman performs a useful role in pointing to the bankruptcy of “Right” as well as “Left” in Israel. He is aware that this absence of principled leadership poses the greatest dangers for Israel, for the Jews of Israel, as well as the Jews in the Diaspora, including in America who are losing their Jewishness, and are being absorbed into the forces of American Imperialism.

 

However Martin Sherman tries to fix the problem from within the Jewish ideology of Judaism (more or less) and he cannot go outside of the Jewish experience, towards Trotskyism.

 

Sherman with many others is correct in identifying the two factors, geographical and demographic, as being central issues.

 

Sherman proposes paying Arabs in Palestine who want to leave and create a future for themselves a notable grant which may well be appealing.

 

This however, ALTOUGH 4INTERNATIONAL DOES NOT OPPOSE IT, is a little bit of sidestepping of the issue.

 

The issue that needs to be hammered out inside the international movement including the international working class movement is:

 

  1. Israel is the Homeland of the Jewish people
  2. The issue raises the issue of nation, because the Jews have 4000 years of history as a nation, the longest in existence
  3. This issue of nation runs into conflict with the demands of international capitalism in crisis, and its need for dictatorial central control, wrongly called sometimes “NEW” World Order. Not New…Hitler attempted the same.
  4. The Palestinians are not a nation but a carefully manufactured concept of Antisemitism existing since roughly 1967. It is a meme becoming a law through repetition. That is the central thing that must be tackled head on.
  5. The issue of nation also runs into conflict with modern day anti-Marxists because although there was a tendency to dismiss Nation (for obvious reasons) by the time of Leon Trotsky in the 1930s, the main socialist revolutionary leader of the times there was a serious reversal by Leon Trotsky. Trotsky came to stand for Jewish nation and for Ukrainian nation (and Nationhoods)

 

 

These are issues that are far more important than paying these “Palestinians” to find a home elsewhere. That is a tactic that CAN be used but it is only a tactic. The concept of the Jewish Homeland and Nation must be advanced far more as a priority. I notice that Sherman was given support by a character called “Curious American” who advances the Palestinian Fascist cause continually. That is the danger.

 

4international is also opposed to all concepts of A B or C including the hundreds of variations as advanced often by that centrist Jew Ted Belman. 4international says to Belman state your ground and fight for it.

 

Lay down the basis. The International People laid down the law in the early 1920s. Jordan is the Jewish Homeland, and still is. Certainly is Golan, Gaza, and Judea and Samaria, as well as Israel as it is today. All that was stolen from the Jews by World Antisemitism. Sinai was won in rightful struggle.

 

That is the position of 4international. THAT is the position that the centrist Ted Belman could never hold.

 

Towards that position we hold and along the way we are prepared to advance tactically. We may accept temporary compromise but on principles never veer from.

 

Only a Trotskyist Party can advance both tactically and strategically, both concepts which are in a unity and conflict of opposites. The conflict between the two have to be kept inside of the unity.

 

We are in a new period. We do not want to be messing around with bank balances. We want to advance a revolutionary and a strategic programme.

 

A/ Only Jews live in Israel. All others, that is non-Jewish, are there by invitation, they are guests and if they understand that they are guest they can be honoured guests.

B/ Israel is what was laid down by the International Peoples in 1920 as outlined above

C/ The struggle against Fascism, Racism, Antisemitism today is meaningless if the above concept of Israel is not fought for. That is what distinguishes 4international as revolutionaries today, and as being against anti-Marxist leftist pro-Fascists…

NETANYAHU IS A TOTAL TRAITOR AND MUST BE FORCED TO WITHDRAW FROM TALKS

Netanyahu is a traitor to the Jews.

Absolutely totally it is not possible to have an agreement with the Palestinian Arabs because they are the Jihad. The name “Palestinians” equals Jihad!

It is in the nature of the Jihad to destroy Israel.

(See my other posts in recent days that Israeli leaders are ignoring the US and Fascist plans in Ukraine to destroy Russia. This post on Jihad is related not separate in any way)

The argument of Netanyahu and many others in the Israeli elite leaders is false to the core and is most dangerous indeed, involving millions of Jewish lives.

In its essentials Netanyahu is saying that these JIHADISTS called the “Palestinians” must recognize Israel.

That is a nonsense!

As is presented by Netanyahu on the eve of Merkel visiting Israel that is the most dangerous trap for Jews that Netanyahu is setting for the Jews.

It is written into the laws of the Koran and the Jihad that it is permissible to lie to the Kuffir.

So Netanyahu is placing the lives of millions of Jews on the line because he is disregarding this historical and contemporary truth.

It is a lie that the Jihadists, that is the Palestinian Arabs, can or ever will recognise Israel. Who is propagating the lie? Make no mistake at all it is Netanyahu and other traitors like Peres.

There is nothing at all to stop the Jihadists from SAYING that they recognise Israel. Indeed that is what Arafat did in the OSLO accords. Arafat said in English that of course he recognised Israel bla bla bla. Arafat said it hundreds of times, maybe thousands. But in Arab he said the opposite.

How are Jews today not absolutely clear on this issue!!!

 

Zahir Muhsein said this in 1977:

The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct “Palestinian people” to oppose Zionism.

 

For tactical reasons, Jordan, which is a sovereign state with defined borders, cannot raise claims to Haifa and Jaffa, while as a Palestinian, I can undoubtedly demand Haifa, Jaffa, Beer-Sheva and Jerusalem. However, the moment we reclaim our right to all of Palestine, we will not wait even a minute to unite Palestine and Jordan.

.

The Israelis were mistaken ever to play along with this charade, but it may be too late to get back to reality on that. Netanyahu’s main point, however, is sound: the “Palestinians” won’t accept the existence of the State of Israel, so how can there be a negotiated settlement? Yet they can never accept the existence of Israel, because of the principle in Islamic theology that land governed at one time by Islamic law belongs by right to the Muslims forever. Barack Obama and John Kerry, of course, either don’t know or don’t care about that.

 

“‘I’m Ready To Accept Palestine, Why Not Israel?,’” by Ari Yashar for Israel National News, February 24:

 

 

Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu spoke on Sunday night, emphasizing that the Palestinian Authority’s (PA) refusal to recognize Israel as the Jewish state is the fundamental factor preventing peace. “Recognition of the Jewish state is a necessary condition for peace,” remarked Netanyahu.

 

Speaking to a German television channel in advance of German Chancellor Angela Merkel’s Israel visit on Monday, Netanyahu praised US Secretary of State John Kerry’s efforts to push through a peace deal between Israel and the PA.

 

“The only way to achieve peace is to express support for Kerry’s efforts,” claimed Netanyahu. “Together with the Palestinians, and at their head PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas, we have to sit at the table and reach an agreement.”

 

“I’m ready to accept their existence in their country, why don’t they accept me?” asked Netanyahu, stressing that the refusal to recognize Israel as a Jewish state is a major roadblock to peace.

 

“The obstacle of the peace talks is this principle (of recognition), and not the issue of Israeli building in settlements that gets such wide criticism in the West,” argued Netanyahu. He further denied claims that construction is a key problem, saying it’s an issue that “will be solved in the talks’ framework.”

 

Last Friday, US Ambassador to Israel Dan Shapiro declared the PA will be required to recognize Israel as a Jewish state in any framework agreement, a day after a PLO (Palestinian Liberation Organization) official claimed Abbas was ready to recognize Israel.

 

Abbas’s PA has previously said the Arab states “will never recognize Israel,” and as noted has repeatedly refused to recognize Israel. On Sunday, Hamas lawmakers warned that recognition of Israel would be a “death sentence” for the PA.

 

Kerry’s has reportedly proposed that Israel would be forced to “earn” PA recognition as a Jewish state by obligating itself through guarantees that it will not compromise the status of Israeli Arabs.

That is from Jihadwatch and we support Robert Spencer on this. he makes essentially the SAME points as we on 4international.me. But when you look at the comments there you will find total confusión. Please read them. You will understand how deep is the crisis in Jewish leadership.

What is the answer. Naftali Bennett in the Hard Talk interview made one key point above all, and that is that the Jewish youth today and in general the Jews overall are opposed to the Netanyahu programme.

Please understand me and act now before it is too late.

There is needed urgently a new and a revolutionary party in Israel. Please do not read this and then do nothing. Enter into discussion…what is the way forward. DO NOT HOLD BACK

Do read those comments I mentioned on http://www.jihadwatch.org/2014/02/netanyahu-im-ready-to-accept-palestine-but-they-wont-accept-israel

NETANYAHU RELIES ON EGYPT FOR SECURITY AND TABA BUS BOMB HAPPENS

Muslim Brotherhood terrorists exploded a bomb on a bus travelling through Sinai to cross the border with Israel at the Taba border crossing, which is a short distance from the city of Eilat at the southern tip of Israel.

 

This exposes once again the real bankruptcy of Israeli leaders and especially Netanyahu. These Israeli leaders cannot protect Jews from terrorists and they cannot protect visitors to Israel either, in this case Christians from South Korea. Sinai in both Judaism and Christianity is a holy place.

 

Netanyahu makes a big mistake in trusting the Egyptian Government to keep order against Islamists in Sinai. This trust is linked to the fact that the Israeli leaders are still “lorrying” into Gaza huge amounts of food etc. paid for by Jews. What a farce.

 

Netanyahu also is betraying Jews and the army which opposed the Fascist Flotilla. He is going along like a baby with Obama who insists that Israel apologise and pays a huge sum of money to the arch Antisemite Erdogan of Turkey. What a betrayal.

 

Meanwhile Netanyahu is up to his eyeballs in the plans of Obama and Kerry to drive a stake into the heart of Israel through creating a Palestinian state.

 

Martin Sherman has pointed out continually the bankruptcy of these Israeli Jewish leaders. These leaders (as the Sinai bombing yesterday shows) cannot protect Jews.

 

The crisis in this Israeli Jewish leaders is widespread and is deep.

 

The hypocrite Robert Spencer of Jihadwatch claims to stand for free speech but bans my comments on Jihadwatch.

 

The confused Pamela Geller entertains Antisemites in her comment section

 

The blog run now by Ted Belman entertains as a main commenter on his blog Israpundit an open Fascist. Belman is a weak man and a foolish one at that.

 

Belman cannot defend Israel because he keeps a Fascist on his site who continually attacks Christians.

 

Think of the damage this bus bombing has caused to many people, Christians, in Southern Korea.

 

The security at the Taba crossing by Israel was the worst possible. They were relying on Egypt to look after security.

 

There needs to be new leadership, a Trotskyist leadership.

 

All these who attack Trotsky and Trotskyism we will answer. The Jewish movement has to clear its ranks of such Fascists, mostly inspired by US Imperialism.

 

The immediate consequence of the Taba bombing of the Korean Christian people on that bus means one thing above all.

 

Israel is being cornered by 1. World Antisemites and 2. Jewish traitors to Israel like I have outlined above.

 

There needs to be a revolutionary government in Israel. Israel must take control of Sinai and be prepared to fight a war to do so.

 

Gaza must immediately be taken under Israeli control and the Hamas Party broken up totally. Let the sponsors of Hamas which is the Obama Government take them all to America

THE WHOLE OF THE ISRAELI RULING CLASS ARE TRAITORS TO THE JEWS…OUR ANSWER TO MARTIN SHERMAN

Gaza Betrayal by Jewish leaders

TED BELMAN OF ISRAPUNDIT TAKES CENTRIST POSITION ON NETANYAHU

The issue was really over the nature of the whole Israeli ruling class, whatever they may be called. The disagreement between Ted Belman editor of Israpundit and Francisco Gil White was about that.

Gil White had called Netanyahu a traitor. I agreed with him but I go much further because I call the whole of the Israeli leaders right across the board traitors. Big difference. But let us not stray. How did Belman react to Gil White? It is most instructive to see what Belman wrore:

I disagree with Gil-White’s conclusion.  Everyone involved with Oslo from the start knew of the Nazi connection and chose to ignore it.  I don’t see continuing it as treason but as stupidity or naivete.  Ted Belman

 

http://www.israpundit.com/archives/63591148

 

A strange response by Ted Belman

 

USEFUL ANALOGY

A similar situation is that your friend is being conned by a conman out of his life savings and you sitting there beside your friend while this is going on know he is a conman, but your friend does not, and you say nothing. If you do that you are not a friend, not naive, not stupid, but you are a traitor to your friend

 

The same applies with all these political leaders in Israel. Call them right call them left, whatever (AND if you do that just shows your political and historical ignorance)

 

MORE ON THE CONMAN ANALOGY

The Jews are being continually conned here by the US Government. They were conned over OSLO, conned over the Gaza withdrawal, conned by Churchill over Jordan, conned by the UN in 1948.

 

But on this score the US Government would not have been able to con the Jews if it had not been for the Jewish leadership in Israel.

 

The Likud leadership knew exactly what Sharon was doing in 2005 and yet the Likud leaders refused to act against Sharon. There was lots of time and the very first thing the Likud leaders should have done was expel the TRAITOR.  (To add to my argument who emerged as the greatest traitors of the Jews during the Gaza removal? It was the rabbis and the Settlers leaders!)

 

While all this was going on Netanyahu was there but he basically was lying low, and he only put up a bit of a show at the very end, when it was too late, and moreover he knew it was too late. How do you characterise this kind of behaviour, naïve!!! No traitors to the Jews. All human activity is conscious.

SO WHY DID BELMAN CALL NETANYAHU NAIVE?

 

SHERMAN ALSO THINKS THEY ARE “NAIVE”

SHERMAN HAS ILLUSIONS IN ISRAEL POLITICIANS

Note that these are what is called the right

  1. Netanyahu made his name as a right politician
  2. Likud to a man and woman is opposed to socialism

Now since this is about Martin Sherman what about him? Well Sherman looks at the situation in Israel and does 2 things

 

  1. Sherman like Belman thinks that the Likud and Right are also naive
  2. While he sees the right as naive only Sherman then confuses the issue totally by referring to what he calls the “left” thus echoing the confusers supreme on this score Geller and Spencer.

Those therefore are two big problems about Sherman.

BUT SHERMAN IS BETTER THAN THE TOTAL CONFUSIONIST CAROLINE GLICK

In his article Sherman makes this reference to Glick:

Regrettably, however, most of these are poorly thought through, and even if implemented, would leave Israel, as the nation-state of the Jewish people, in a situation hardly less beleaguered – diplomatically, politically and physically – than if it adopted the perilous prescription of the Left.

Typically, these alternative proposals fall into three broad categories. (a) Those that would leave Israel with a massive enfranchised Muslim minority (up to 40%) within its frontiers, critically undermining the ability to maintain the dominant Jewish character of the state, whatever the initial electoral arithmetic; (b) those that would leave Israel with excessively long and torturous frontiers, impossible to delineate (other than on a map) and to secure; and (c) those that entail both (a) and (b).

Most of these alternative proposals draw on optimistic (but not necessarily unrealistic) demographic assumptions as to the growth of the Arab population, but pay little heed to the negative effect the proposals might have on the Jewish population, were they to be implemented.

Lamentably, by insisting on blatantly flawed and clearly counter-productive political paradigms as proffered alternatives to the Left’s prescription of appeasement and accommodation, the authors of these proposals and their supporters only bolster the false perception that the latter is the only game in town

In the above Sherman is attacking Caroline Glick. You would hardly know but he is.

That is the good thing about Sherman…he is clear that the Glick proposals are the proposals of somebody who is betraying the Jews. Yes to leave 40 per cent of Muslims inside her Israel, that is a Glick betrayal right there and Sherman calls her on this betrayal.

At least Sherman is clear on the betrayal of Glick.

But there is no way forward at all with Sherman. Jews need a new leadership.